Opens in a new tab

A Missed Cancer and a Delayed Diagnosis in New York – How the Law Counts the Time to File a Malpractice Case

Test results that were never followed up. A tumor visible on a scan that nobody reported. When patients learn about their illness years later, they ask whether it is already too late. The Stein Law Group, led by attorney Adam J. Stein, explains how deadlines work in these cases.

Adwokat wypadkowy nowy jork adam stein esq
The Stein Law Group
August 30, 2026
Doctor reviewing diagnostic scans on a computer monitor
A delayed cancer diagnosis case rests on the complete medical record. Photo: Shutterstock

Attorney Advertising

In New York, a medical malpractice case generally must be filed within 2.5 years. For a missed cancer diagnosis there is an exception known as Lavern’s Law: the 2.5 years run from when the patient knew or should have known of the error, but no later than 7 years after the negligent act itself.

A delayed diagnosis is one of the hardest kinds of medical cases. Patients often have no idea for a long time that anything went wrong. They find out only when another doctor shows them their old results and says, “this was visible two years ago.” The Stein Law Group explains what happens to the deadlines at that point and where the review of such a case begins.

What a delayed diagnosis means

Not every illness found late is a doctor’s mistake. Medicine offers no guarantees, and some cancers cause no symptoms for a long time. An error exists when a doctor or facility failed to do what a careful doctor should have done in the same situation. Typical examples include:

  • an abnormal test result the patient was never told about;
  • a change visible on an X-ray, CT scan or mammogram that was not reported;
  • no referral for further testing despite worrying symptoms;
  • a recommended follow-up that nobody made sure happened.

Lavern’s Law – an exception for missed cancer

For years, the deadline for a medical malpractice case in New York was counted from the date of the negligent act itself. A patient who learned of a missed cancer three years later could be told it was already too late, even though there had been no way to know sooner. That changed with a law passed in January 2018 and named Lavern’s Law, after a New York City patient whose lung cancer was not detected in time.

Under this law, in cases involving a failure to diagnose cancer or a malignant tumor, the 2.5-year period runs from the date the patient knew – or with reasonable attention should have known – of the negligence and of the harm it caused. There is a limit, however: the case cannot be filed later than 7 years after the negligent act. The exception applies only to cancer; other conditions follow the general rules. Separately, continuous treatment by the same provider for the same condition can also delay the start of the deadline.

City hospitals – shorter deadlines

If treatment took place at a hospital or clinic in the city’s NYC Health + Hospitals system, additional requirements for public entities apply. Generally, a notice of claim must be filed within 90 days, and the deadlines for suing a public entity are counted under separate rules. That is why the first question in every medical case is where, and by whom, the patient was treated.

Where the review of the case begins

A delayed diagnosis case rests on medical records. The firm starts by gathering the full treatment history: test results, imaging reports, visit notes and referrals. The records are then reviewed by an independent physician in the relevant specialty – without that opinion, such a case cannot move forward in New York.

The patient or family can help by preparing:

  • a list of doctors and facilities that provided treatment, with approximate dates;
  • copies of results and printouts from the patient portal;
  • the dates when the patient reported symptoms;
  • when, and from whom, the patient received the correct diagnosis.

Treatment comes first

Talking to the firm should never delay treatment or a change of doctor. The firm does not need the patient to interrupt therapy – information and permission to collect records are enough. In many cases, it is the family that makes the first call while the patient is still in treatment.

Read also: Wrongful Death in New York – Who Can File the Case · Nursing Home Admission Agreement in NY – Arbitration · SSDI and Workers’ Comp in NY – How the 80% Offset Works

Attorney Adam J. Stein, Esq. handles medical malpractice cases in New York and New Jersey. The Stein Law Group, PLLC has its main offices in Greenpoint (144 Nassau Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11222) and Maspeth (57-53 61st Street, Maspeth, NY 11378). The first conversation with the firm’s team is always in Polish, and the consultation is free. Phone: 718-383-0100. Full details – The Stein Law Group profile in the Polish Pages directory.

This article is for general information only and is not legal or medical advice; reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship. Every case requires individual review. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Sponsored Content

Disclaimer: The editorial staff is not responsible for the content, accuracy, or timeliness of this article. For any inquiries, please contact the author directly. Images used in this article are for illustrative purposes only.

Poland.Us Newsletter

Post
Filter