Attorney Advertising
After a work injury in New York, you can receive Workers’ Compensation and federal SSDI at the same time. But if together they exceed 80% of your average current earnings before the disability, Social Security cuts SSDI by the difference – until full retirement age or until Workers’ Compensation stops.
After a serious injury on a construction site, in a warehouse or while cleaning offices, many people get conflicting advice: “take Workers’ Comp,” “apply for disability,” “you can’t have both.” In reality, these are two separate systems – one run by the state, one by the federal government – with different rules and different agencies. The Stein Law Group explains how the benefits fit together and where the most common misunderstandings come from.
Workers’ Compensation and SSDI are two different systems
Workers’ Compensation is New York’s state insurance system for job-related injuries and illnesses. It covers medical treatment and replaces part of lost wages. Cases are handled by the New York State Workers’ Compensation Board, and benefits are paid by the employer’s insurance carrier.
SSDI (Social Security Disability Insurance) is a federal benefit paid by the Social Security Administration. It does not matter whether the injury happened at work, at home or on the street. Two things count: enough work history with Social Security taxes paid, and a medical condition that meets the federal definition of disability.
That is why a Workers’ Compensation decision or a doctor’s note saying you cannot work does not automatically entitle you to SSDI. Social Security reviews the claim on its own, using its own criteria.
When Social Security considers you disabled
Under Social Security’s rules, an SSDI applicant must be unable to work at the level of “substantial gainful activity” because of a medical condition that has lasted, or is expected to last, at least 12 months or to result in death. No benefits are paid for partial or short-term disability.
There is generally a five-month waiting period as well. The first benefit is paid for the sixth full month after the date Social Security decides the disability began. After two years of receiving disability benefits, you are automatically enrolled in Medicare.
In practice, Workers’ Compensation usually starts much sooner. SSDI comes into play when an injury turns out to be long-term and keeps you from doing any work at all – not just your old job.
The 80% cap – how the SSDI offset works
You can collect both benefits at once, with a limit. As Social Security explains in its publication on how Workers’ Compensation affects benefits, SSDI plus Workers’ Compensation (and other public disability benefits) cannot exceed 80% of your average current earnings before the disability. Anything above that is subtracted from your SSDI.
The reduction lasts until the month you reach full retirement age or the month your Workers’ Compensation payments stop, whichever comes first.
Not every benefit counts toward the cap. Social Security lists, among others, private disability insurance, Veterans Administration benefits, state and local government benefits if Social Security taxes were withheld from your earnings, and SSI.
Settling a Workers’ Compensation case while on SSDI
Many Workers’ Compensation cases end with a lump-sum payment instead of weekly checks. Social Security says a lump sum must be reported right away, because it can also affect SSDI – including benefits paid to family members.
The wording of the settlement matters. Under Social Security’s operating guidelines, the agency first prorates a lump sum using the rate stated in the settlement document. If no rate is stated, other rules apply, and as a last resort the state’s maximum weekly rate. Documented medical costs and attorney’s fees may be excluded from the calculation.
So before signing a Workers’ Compensation settlement, it is worth checking how its language will affect your current or future Social Security benefit.
What to gather before decisions are made
- your Workers’ Compensation Board case number and any decisions issued;
- medical records starting with the first visit after the accident;
- pay stubs and your work history for recent years;
- every letter from Social Security, including decisions and requests;
- a draft settlement, if the insurance carrier has offered one.
Any change in Workers’ Compensation – an increase, a decrease or the end of payments – must be reported to Social Security. Late reporting can lead to a demand to repay an overpayment.
Read also: Company Vehicle Accident in NY – Workers’ Comp or Car Case? · Fired After Reporting a Work Injury in NY – Retaliation · Ladder Fall During Home Renovation in NY – Who Is Liable
Attorney Adam J. Stein, Esq. handles workplace injury and Workers’ Compensation cases in New York and New Jersey. The Stein Law Group, PLLC has its main offices in Greenpoint (144 Nassau Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11222) and Maspeth (57-53 61st Street, Maspeth, NY 11378). The first conversation with the firm’s team is always in Polish, and the consultation is free. Phone: 718-383-0100. Contact details – The Stein Law Group profile in the Polish Pages directory.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship. Every case requires individual review. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.















