Attorney Advertising
Several parties may be responsible for a fall on an icy store parking lot or entrance in New York: the retail tenant, the property owner and the snow removal contractor. Who is liable depends on the contracts between them, the weather and how long the hazard was visible.
Winter in New York is the season of falls. Most of them happen not in the middle of the street, but in places we hurry through: store parking lots, entrance steps, cart corrals and driveways. The injured person usually assumes “the store” is responsible. In practice, the case is often more complicated.
Why several companies answer for one parking lot
Large stores rarely own the building and the lot. They usually lease the space from a property owner and hire an outside company for snow removal – or the shopping center owner does it for all tenants. The lease determines who must maintain the lot, the sidewalk and the entrance. The snow removal contract determines when that company must show up and what it must do. A snow removal contractor is liable to a person who falls only in certain situations – for example, when its work created or worsened the icy condition, or when its contract fully took over the owner’s duty to maintain the area. That is why the contract terms matter so much.
For the injured person, this means identifying every party connected with the place of the fall from the start. Focusing on only one of them may simply allow that one to point at someone else.
The duty to clear snow and the time to respond
New York City rules require building owners and managers to clear the sidewalk in front of their property within a set time after snowfall ends. Under the city Sanitation Department’s rules, if snow stops between 7 AM and 5 PM, the sidewalk must be cleared within 4 hours; between 5 PM and 9 PM, within 14 hours; and between 9 PM and 7 AM, by 11 AM. These deadlines apply to sidewalks and city fines; in an injury case – including a fall in a parking lot – the court mainly asks whether the owner had a reasonable time to clear the snow and ice.
New York courts also apply a rule known as the storm-in-progress doctrine: while a storm is ongoing, an owner is generally not liable for snow that is still falling. Liability may arise once a reasonable time to respond has passed after the storm and the area is still dangerous – or when snow removal was done in a way that made things worse, for example by leaving piles that melt and refreeze into ice.
What is reviewed after a fall on ice
- when the snowfall ended and how much time passed before the fall – weather data for that day;
- whether the area was salted or sanded, and when;
- whether anyone had reported the slippery spot before – customers, employees, drivers;
- whether ice formed in the same place regularly, for example under a downspout or on a poorly graded driveway;
- who was responsible for that part of the property under the contracts.
Store and parking lot cameras may show what the ground looked like and who cleared it. It is worth asking for that footage to be preserved as soon as possible.
A fall on public property
If the fall happened on property owned by the city or a public agency – for example next to a city building or at a bus stop – special, short deadlines apply. A claim against the City of New York generally requires a formal notice of claim within 90 days of the incident. The lawsuit itself generally must be filed within one year and 90 days of the incident. Missing these deadlines can end the case.
First steps after a fall outside a store
- report the fall to the store manager and ask for a copy or number of the incident report;
- photograph the spot, your footwear and the ice before the area is salted;
- write down witnesses’ contact details;
- see a doctor the same day, even if the pain seems minor.
Read also: Ladder Fall During Home Renovation in NY – Who Is Liable · Truck or Delivery Van Accident in New York – Who Is Liable · Wrongful Death in New York – Who Can File the Case
Attorney Adam J. Stein, Esq. handles slip-and-fall cases, including falls at large stores, in New York and New Jersey. The Stein Law Group, PLLC has its main offices in Greenpoint (144 Nassau Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11222) and Maspeth (57-53 61st Street, Maspeth, NY 11378). The first conversation with the firm’s team is always in Polish, and the consultation is free. Phone: 718-383-0100. Contact details – The Stein Law Group profile in the Polish Pages directory.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship. Every case requires individual review. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.















